After six-of-eight unanimous picks in our Round of 16 column, we have only one unanimous pick this time around: Bayern Munich over Manchester United.
Here's how it all broke down, including predictions of the aggregate scores:
| MATCHUP | Andrew Laird | Mike Gottlieb | Nick Pitner | Jim Riggio | Rod Richenberg | Chris Mosinski | Garry Irwin | C.J. Radune |
| Barcelona vs. Atletico Madrid | Barca 3-2 | Barca 4-3 | Barca 4-3 | Barca 6-2 | Atletico 5-3 | Barca 5-3 | Barca 5-3 | Barca 3-1 |
| Manchester United vs. Bayern Munich | Bayern 6-2 | Bayern 4-1 | Bayern 5-2 | Bayern 5-2 | Bayern 4-2 | Bayern 3-1 | Bayern 3-2 | Bayern 4-0 |
| Paris Saint-Germain vs. Chelsea | PSG 4-3 | Chelsea 2-2 (PKs) | PSG 3-3 (PKs) | PSG 4-4 (away goals) | Chelsea 3-2 | Chelsea 2-1 | Chelsea 3-2 | PSG 3-2 |
| Real Madrid vs. Borussia Dortmund | Madrid 7-5 | Madrid 5-3 | Madrid 6-5 | Madrid 4-3 | Madrid 5-2 | Madrid 5-1 | Madrid 6-4 | Dortmund 3-2 |
